Comments on: Blender Conference 2007 Suzanne Awards Winners http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/ Fresh Blender News, Every Day Mon, 01 Dec 2008 11:34:30 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.3 By: Johan http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-179075 Johan Fri, 19 Oct 2007 14:20:23 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-179075 Shrek sucks! Shrek sucks!

]]> By: ERM http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177934 ERM Wed, 17 Oct 2007 13:12:00 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177934 Sago, You accidentally have your website address as peach.blender.com which is nothing since Blender [the mustic] magazine is not working on The Peach Project. I was a bit confused until I tried peach.blender.org and it worked! Sago,

You accidentally have your website address as peach.blender.com which is nothing since Blender [the mustic] magazine is not working on The Peach Project. I was a bit confused until I tried peach.blender.org and it worked!

]]> By: mallow http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177771 mallow Wed, 17 Oct 2007 09:27:51 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177771 If you don`t mind, I`ve copied few answers to blenderartists forum: http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?p=967218#post967218 Maybe we should continue this discussion there, because I think that this is important to make some changes in the festival to make it even better next year. Please leave your comments there. Here on blendernation it will get lost if few more news will appear. If you don`t mind, I`ve copied few answers to blenderartists forum:
http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?p=967218#post967218
Maybe we should continue this discussion there, because I think that this is important to make some changes in the festival to make it even better next year. Please leave your comments there. Here on blendernation it will get lost if few more news will appear.

]]> By: delaney http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177726 delaney Wed, 17 Oct 2007 08:01:12 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177726 Hi guys, really exciting works in here, keep it up ! Mallow : by the way "Apocalypse Now" won the golden palm in Cannes festival with an unfinished version ! :) Hi guys,

really exciting works in here, keep it up !

Mallow : by the way "Apocalypse Now" won the golden palm in Cannes festival with an unfinished version ! :)

]]> By: mallow http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177436 mallow Tue, 16 Oct 2007 22:54:15 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177436 Sago: Hehe :) But why not? I mean these two things are different in many ways, but have something in common. It`s all about the films. I don`t say that Suzanne Awards will be some day as important as Oscars (of course, never will), but if you want to learn, than do it from the best. And there`s still many things that can be done better. Jury for example: Suzanne Awards don`t have one. People vote for the best film. Why is that? I think that there should be a jury. Of course there could be a special prize by the people`s votes, but the winners in main categories should be chosen by jury, if you ask me. I think the main thing is: is the Suzanne Awards Festival just for fun or do we want to promote people who make good films, encourage others to work and learn more, etc. What I mean is the more better the films, the tougher competition, the more interesting festival, the better promotion of Blender - and when Blender gets even more popular, more people use them, more films will be made leading to more submitions to the festival and so on. Full circle. And about the Oscars again - it`s hard to compare it with Suzanne Awards, sure. But how old are the Oscars and how old is the Suzanne Awards Festival? First Oscars ceremonies were completly different than the nowodays ceremonies. I think that the Suzanne Awards, being so young festival is doing really well and is on the right track. But why to learn on our own mistakes and wait for 70 years until there`s everything perfect? We should learn from the best. The Oscars are hell good example, but of course not only the Oscars. There are many festivals much closer to the Suzanne Awards formula. OK, that`s all folks ;) I hope you all know that I write all this to provoke a discussion and try to make Suzanne Awards even better. Oh yeah, and about the "Blood" film - I also enjoyed watching this one. In fact, that was my personal favorite. Sago: Hehe :) But why not? I mean these two things are different in many ways, but have something in common. It`s all about the films. I don`t say that Suzanne Awards will be some day as important as Oscars (of course, never will), but if you want to learn, than do it from the best. And there`s still many things that can be done better. Jury for example: Suzanne Awards don`t have one. People vote for the best film. Why is that? I think that there should be a jury. Of course there could be a special prize by the people`s votes, but the winners in main categories should be chosen by jury, if you ask me.
I think the main thing is: is the Suzanne Awards Festival just for fun or do we want to promote people who make good films, encourage others to work and learn more, etc. What I mean is the more better the films, the tougher competition, the more interesting festival, the better promotion of Blender - and when Blender gets even more popular, more people use them, more films will be made leading to more submitions to the festival and so on. Full circle.
And about the Oscars again - it`s hard to compare it with Suzanne Awards, sure. But how old are the Oscars and how old is the Suzanne Awards Festival? First Oscars ceremonies were completly different than the nowodays ceremonies. I think that the Suzanne Awards, being so young festival is doing really well and is on the right track. But why to learn on our own mistakes and wait for 70 years until there`s everything perfect? We should learn from the best. The Oscars are hell good example, but of course not only the Oscars. There are many festivals much closer to the Suzanne Awards formula. OK, that`s all folks ;) I hope you all know that I write all this to provoke a discussion and try to make Suzanne Awards even better.

Oh yeah, and about the "Blood" film - I also enjoyed watching this one. In fact, that was my personal favorite.

]]> By: Sago http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177386 Sago Tue, 16 Oct 2007 20:37:20 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177386 Comparing the Suzanne Awards with the Oscars..... haha, yeah, we do wanna aim high..... but the oscars?..... good one, Mallow! Btw, one of my favourites of the festival was Blood. Didn't win though, but very cool. Comparing the Suzanne Awards with the Oscars….. haha, yeah, we do wanna aim high….. but the oscars?….. good one, Mallow!

Btw, one of my favourites of the festival was Blood. Didn't win though, but very cool.

]]> By: mallow http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177338 mallow Tue, 16 Oct 2007 18:21:05 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177338 Jussi: what I mean is that it would be better for you (as the authors) if the film was finished. It would look even better than now (and as I said I enjoyed watching it already). So a tip for next time: don`t hurry. Finish your film, add music, cut some scenes that are too long, postprocess the video and boom, your film is 2 times better. And also consider this situation: imagine that you watch the Oscars Ceremony and nominated Shrek 3 isn`t a finished movie. What would you think then? That would be strange, don`t you think? I know that Suzanne Awards is still very young festival and that`s why there are few things that could be better. To the "...Dead Pixels" team: congratulations to you again. I really wish you all the best and hope I could watch some new movies from you soon. The reason why I`m writing all this: I think that all the competitors and the Suzanne Awards Festival would look 100% PRO if the movies in the Best Short Film category would all be finished movies. P.s. Sorry for my English, but I think you understand what I mean. Cheers Jussi: what I mean is that it would be better for you (as the authors) if the film was finished. It would look even better than now (and as I said I enjoyed watching it already). So a tip for next time: don`t hurry. Finish your film, add music, cut some scenes that are too long, postprocess the video and boom, your film is 2 times better.
And also consider this situation: imagine that you watch the Oscars Ceremony and nominated Shrek 3 isn`t a finished movie. What would you think then? That would be strange, don`t you think?
I know that Suzanne Awards is still very young festival and that`s why there are few things that could be better.
To the "…Dead Pixels" team: congratulations to you again. I really wish you all the best and hope I could watch some new movies from you soon. The reason why I`m writing all this: I think that all the competitors and the Suzanne Awards Festival would look 100% PRO if the movies in the Best Short Film category would all be finished movies.

P.s. Sorry for my English, but I think you understand what I mean. Cheers

]]> By: Xand http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177323 Xand Tue, 16 Oct 2007 17:28:14 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177323 i can't see any of the video, just three empty places. i'm on vista i can't see any of the video, just three empty places.
i'm on vista

]]> By: Jussi http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177212 Jussi Tue, 16 Oct 2007 12:42:29 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177212 mallow: As one of the three guys involved I feel I should respond to this. Yeah, the version we sent to the awards was not totally complete, but it didn't lack anything critical (yeah, music makes a huge difference, but it was still quite enjoyable without it). It's not like we sent an animation that ended abruptly story-wise. We can call that copy "a festival version". Since we spent most of the summer working on the thing (as an internship at our school) we wanted (and still want) to get as much feedback as possible. Hence the decision to send a version without music to Suzanne. A year from now the animation probly feels tad old and getting criticism of the things that don't work in it wouldn't be as effective as now that we haven't yet moved on to next projects... So, I'm glad our animation was selected for the Awards in it's unpolished form and received some interest and giggles (judging from the unofficial video posted here somewhere). thanks, j mallow:

As one of the three guys involved I feel I should respond to this.

Yeah, the version we sent to the awards was not totally complete, but it didn't lack anything critical (yeah, music makes a huge difference, but it was still quite enjoyable without it). It's not like we sent an animation that ended abruptly story-wise. We can call that copy "a festival version".

Since we spent most of the summer working on the thing (as an internship at our school) we wanted (and still want) to get as much feedback as possible. Hence the decision to send a version without music to Suzanne. A year from now the animation probly feels tad old and getting criticism of the things that don't work in it wouldn't be as effective as now that we haven't yet moved on to next projects…

So, I'm glad our animation was selected for the Awards in it's unpolished form and received some interest and giggles (judging from the unofficial video posted here somewhere).

thanks,

j

]]> By: basse http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177181 basse Tue, 16 Oct 2007 12:16:51 +0000 http://www.blendernation.com/2007/10/15/blender-conference-2007-suzanne-awards-winners/#comment-177181 mallow: well, even if it's not finished, it's finnish. so that should be enough! but seriously, it's full short... it's not a blender test, it's not couple of minutes of something, but it's a short movie with a plot. and in a way, it's finished. yes, they are going to tweak it... but i dont see anything wrong with that. surely we all know how hard it is to call anything finished. .b mallow: well, even if it's not finished, it's finnish. so that should be enough!

but seriously, it's full short… it's not a blender test, it's not couple of minutes of something, but it's a short movie with a plot. and in a way, it's finished. yes, they are going to tweak it… but i dont see anything wrong with that. surely we all know how hard it is to call anything finished.

.b

]]>